Recently saw a post from a non-Christian reminding his friends to try to guilt Christians into loving what he called their neighbors, basically everyone. Not everyone is a neighbor.
With the Parable of the Good Samaritan Christ taught us that it was the man who behaved as a Christian who was the neighbor. It was not the thieves, the priest nor the Levite. Scripture says that if you love enemies of Christ you will be considered guilty of their evil deeds. Not everyone is your neighbor or brother.
Don’t listen to non-Christians tell you about scripture. It is not their book to use against you.